- Joined
- Jan 25, 2012
- Messages
- 205
- Motherboard
- GA-Z390-AORUS-PRO-WIFI
- CPU
- i9-9900K
- Graphics
- RX 580
- Mac
- Mobile Phone
Long story short: I have 4 CustoMacs and I have been using the same serial numbers, apple ID for years for all of them. I had issues during that period Apple blocked iMessage and created all that fuss, however iMessage, except that period, worked perfectly on all rigs. Suddenly, on one of the rigs, after installing El Cap, iMessage refused to work consistently. I was able to log in, even receive messages from other devices - sometimes - however most of the time not able to send. When logging out from iMessage, "An error occurred during authentication" red message would pop up. I have lived with this one rig not having iMessage working until today when I decided to really get to the bottom of it. A note that I have followed the "How to fix iMessage" post numerous times, deleted files and folders, changing system definition, changing even Apple ID password and still didn't work.
Today, after another hour or so of tries and failures, I had the inspiration to use the iCloud.com ID to log in instead of my regular apple ID. And what a surprise: the stupid iMessage started to work again! I have not tried to use the me.com ID, it might work with that as well. To clarify, I am using my regular apple ID to log in everywhere except iMessage: iCloud, FaceTime (yes, it worked always), Apple Store, iTunes. It's just for iMessage I used iCloud.com.
That said, I don't think it's the primary account the issue. Otherwise I wouldn't expect iMessage to work on the the other 3 CustoMacs either. Something is about this rig (and the Apple server?) that just wants the iCloud.com account instead of the primary account. It goes w/o saying that the iCloud and primary account have the same password.
Perhaps this has been discussed somewhere in those over 593 pages but didn't have the patience to read them all Hopefully the above will help someone.
EDIT: Well, not so great news. After it worked one day, Mr. iMessage stopped working again. FaceTime still works, as expected. Got excited too soon
EDIT2: OK, I am officially puzzled and I am losing it, slowly, slowly. As of today, 27-Jul, the damn thing started working again. Using iMessage as we speak from that questionable rig. Let's see how long will last.
Today, after another hour or so of tries and failures, I had the inspiration to use the iCloud.com ID to log in instead of my regular apple ID. And what a surprise: the stupid iMessage started to work again! I have not tried to use the me.com ID, it might work with that as well. To clarify, I am using my regular apple ID to log in everywhere except iMessage: iCloud, FaceTime (yes, it worked always), Apple Store, iTunes. It's just for iMessage I used iCloud.com.
That said, I don't think it's the primary account the issue. Otherwise I wouldn't expect iMessage to work on the the other 3 CustoMacs either. Something is about this rig (and the Apple server?) that just wants the iCloud.com account instead of the primary account. It goes w/o saying that the iCloud and primary account have the same password.
Perhaps this has been discussed somewhere in those over 593 pages but didn't have the patience to read them all Hopefully the above will help someone.
EDIT: Well, not so great news. After it worked one day, Mr. iMessage stopped working again. FaceTime still works, as expected. Got excited too soon
EDIT2: OK, I am officially puzzled and I am losing it, slowly, slowly. As of today, 27-Jul, the damn thing started working again. Using iMessage as we speak from that questionable rig. Let's see how long will last.
Last edited: