Instructions feedback (as we talked about a couple of days ago):
First off, just want to say again that your Guide is really, truly excellent! These are just a few suggestions for clarity (mostly for newb-eyes).
1) In Step 2, under “Summary of BIOS Setting Changes”, the
BIOS categories show up
out-of-order (compared to order onscreen). It would be easier for users to accurately work their way down the list if the order matched the screen.
2) In Step 4, there is a picture of /EFI/CLOVER/kexts/Other which shows
IntelMausiEthernet.kext’. But for those following instructions
exactly,
it will not be there (as it’s been installed by MultiBeast over in /L/E, which is enough for most people’s purposes). Perhaps it’s worth adding a few words about it only being needed in /E/C/k/Other for Recovery/TimeMachine on a NAS?
3) In the "select country" screen it’s
great that you have the text “
..do not sign in to iCloud at this time” in red. In addition, I suggest BOLD for "
Choose Setup Later" just beyond the red. Someone just scanning down to find their place (after they’ve completed a step) can easily miss/skip the next action step, if the formatting doesn’t separate it out. Seems minor, but this is an important one; if they have tried to sign into iCloud with the default S/N… then fixing iMessage/iClould/Handoff/etc becomes rather detailed and/or difficult.
4)
Broken link: in the section “For Video Editors and Graphic Designers”, the first link to “iDiot's Guide to Lilu and it's Plugins” doesn’t link to your intended target. The second one (next to the TM icon) works.
5) Your good post in the great Backups thread is
too well-hidden ("
Easy Way to make a Bootable Clone of your macOS System Drive". Perhaps
add a link to it at the end of the OptiMac Guide? Being buried on page 4 of a different thread means many people won’t find it. I know that you referred to it recently on OptiMac Page 58 (Post 571)… but same thing about people finding it. The word "
Backup" does not appear on the full first page of the OptiMac Guide.
6)
Lilu & WEG updates. For me, Lilu = 1.3.8 and WEG = 1.3.2 in /L/E folder has been working fine. Maybe some words about how updating in the /EFI/CLOVER/kexts/Other but not /L/E/ is not
really the change or update they might think it is?
Many people don’t understand Clover’s “Inject Kexts” logic, and the fact that the ‘live’ kext over in /L/E is what matters for normal operation. Perhaps a link (towards the end of your guide) to jaymonkey’s excellent “[GUIDE] Installing 3rd Party Kexts - El Capitan, Sierra, High Sierra, Mojave, Catalina” might help people understand the
how’s and why’s of where kexts need to be placed (and what gets activated). This is one of those blurry lines when writing a Guide: you want it to be comprehensive, but you
also want to get people to go do a touch of learning! I’ve pointed that guide out to people who were going in circles (and wasting tons of time) tweaking their /EFI/CLOVER/kexts/Other folder (but with inject OFF), and I’ve actually been thanked for referring them to it.
Question, not feedback:
Updating Clover to more-recent version: what was the ‘big change’ in the Clover Installer that we’re trying to keep from biting folks? I’m wanting to investigate that a bit!
Suggestion, not feedback:
I have several friends and local users that I assist with their hacks, and I always offer what I consider to be an easy best-practice step:
just after they’ve got their initial setup working well (and
before making that
all-too-critical backup of the initial setup which you've mentioned in the thread), they should
create a “Backup Admin” account.
This can be very useful in the case they bork their main Account and need an alternate Admin-level login to go manually repair things, or to pull data files before a re-install. This is a matter of choice and preference, though.
Thanks again!