Not necessarily. It could just mean the Bios is messed up. It could be a borked motherboard but two in a short time is a bit of a stretch for me.
Your motherboard GA-H97M-D3H has the standard Gigabyte Dual Bios chip. I would try the following before I consigned either motherboard to the rubbish tip. Here is an image showing the general layout of your H97-D3H, which is nearly identical to my Z97-D3H motherboard.
Motherboard layout with connectors listed, check items 14 & 15.
First I would remove the CMOS battery from the motherboard, leave it out for around a minute, replace it and then try rebooting.
Details for CMOS jumper and battery.
Using the jumper is the same as removing the battery. You can short the jumper using the side of a flat blade screwdriver if you don't have a jumper cover to hand.
I would also look to switch the bios from its current setting to the alternative setting, there is no switch/jumper on the motherboard so you would need to follow one of these methods:
3 methods to force the motherboard to use the alternative bios.
Can't hurt to try these fixes, as you may find the boards are not dead just the bios is corrupted and no longer working.
If this fails to bring the boards back to life, then yes, any peripherals should be salvageable from the two Haswell systems, CPU's, memory, hard drives etc.