Lid sleep issue | apple menu sleep or scheduled sleep works fine

[RehabMan]

I have installed ACPIDebug.kext and applied these two DSDT patches:
https://github.com/RehabMan/OS-X-ACPI-Debug/blob/master/debug.txt
https://github.com/RehabMan/OS-X-ACPI-Debug/blob/master/instrument_LID.txt

I'm a bit lost how to proceed now.

edit: console output

standaard    21:15:12.007462 +0100    kernel    ACPIDebug: "LID0._LID enter"
standaard    21:15:12.007832 +0100    kernel    ACPIDebug: { "LID0._LID returning", 0x1, }
standaard    21:15:22.916193 +0100    kernel    ACPIDebug: "LID0._LID enter"
standaard    21:15:22.916584 +0100    kernel    ACPIDebug: { "LID0._LID returning", 0x0, }
21:15:25 LID CLOSED
standaard    21:15:26.509199 +0100    kernel    ACPIBatteryManager: WARNING! fMaxCapacity > fDesignCapacity. adjusted fMaxCapacity from 5305, to 5230
21:15:41 SLEEP? USB DEAD
standaard    21:15:41.760263 +0100    kernel    ACPI SLEEP
standaard    21:15:41.823940 +0100    kernel    ACPI S3 WAKE
standaard    21:15:41.828058 +0100    kernel    ACPIBatteryManager: WARNING! fMaxCapacity > fDesignCapacity. adjusted fMaxCapacity from 5305, to 5230
standaard    21:15:41.835097 +0100    kernel    ACPIDebug: "LID0._LID enter"
standaard    21:15:41.835321 +0100    kernel    ACPIDebug: { "LID0._LID returning", 0x1, }
standaard    21:15:41.836120 +0100    kernel    ACPIDebug: "LID0._LID enter"
standaard    21:15:41.836345 +0100    kernel    ACPIDebug: { "LID0._LID returning", 0x1, }
standaard    21:15:41.840403 +0100    kernel    Wake reason: power-button (User)
standaard    21:15:41.840404 +0100    kernel    Wake reason: power-button (User)
21:16:04 LID OPEN
standaard    21:16:04.652289 +0100    kernel    ACPIDebug: "LID0._LID enter"
standaard    21:16:04.652610 +0100    kernel    ACPIDebug: { "LID0._LID returning", 0x1, }
standaard    21:16:04.654095 +0100    kernel    ACPIDebug: "LID0._LID enter"
standaard    21:16:04.654430 +0100    kernel    ACPIDebug: { "LID0._LID returning", 0x1, }
standaard    21:16:04.655631 +0100    kernel    ACPIBatteryManager: WARNING! fMaxCapacity > fDesignCapacity. adjusted fMaxCapacity from 5305, to 5230
standaard    21:16:14.697661 +0100    kernel    ACPIDebug: "LID0._LID enter"
standaard    21:16:14.698014 +0100    kernel    ACPIDebug: { "LID0._LID returning", 0x1, }

Shutdown does not work after this cycle, also a second cycle results in a black screen...

It looks like _LID is working (it is called and seems to return the expected value for current state of the lid based on ACPI spec). And it looks like closing the lid is triggering sleep.

Your USB/sleep problem could be caused by USB WiFi.
But also, your USB setup is not correct (wrong UsbConnector values).

Also, you might want to instrument the _WAK method (and things it calls) to see if it does anything different when wake is via lid vs. other methods. Think of it like a fun "needle in haystack" sort of project...