Contribute
Register

Approach for a dead silent Haswell Hackintosh

Status
Not open for further replies.
Joined
Jan 2, 2012
Messages
7
Mac
  1. 0
Classic Mac
  1. 0
Mobile Phone
  1. 0
It all started with a Hackintosh build I was going to build for my brother in law. After being annoyed by the noise of the hard disk drive of my 2011 iMac 27" for quite some time I chose to build the same system for myself to save some time and work. However I could not life with the idea of having a regular ATX case underneath my desk (though soon I'd see how much easier this would have been), so I went for a little challenge to modify a G5 case like many others have done before. I had modified a G3 B&W and a G4 QS case to ATX before, so it wasn't completely unknown territory for me. The G5/Mac Pro case is the prettiest case I know to date, so with prices on old G5s dropping there was nothing left to stop me (or so I thought).
The wife is not happy about it at all - replacing the pretty, fully functional iMac with a Dell display and a big thing under the desk...

So the search for a case in good condition could begin. Soon I should find one in very good condition, already been stripped of all the electronics... I bought it, keen on the build to start.

02.jpg

03.jpg

04.jpg


My goal was to build a really silent computer as I tend to be VERY sensitive on unwanted noise. The system had to be fast enough for some work in Adobe Lightroom (a little faster than the i3 in my iMac), besides that there were no real requirements to speak of.
So I started to pick up some new hardware following Tony's excellent guide:

GigaByte GA-Z87MX-D3H
Intel i5 4670
16 GB DDR3 1600
2 TB WD Green
120 GB Samsung 840 Evo
400W BeQuiet! Straight Power E9
TP-Link TL-WDN4800
EKL Alpenföhn Brocken 2
1x Noctua NF-A14-ULN
2x Noctua NF-B9-PWM

01.jpg

You can see some of the hardware I ordered for my brother in law's build too, so it was a nice pile. ;)

For the modifications on the case (eg. the metal work) I knew I didn't have the skills and the tools to reach the level of some of the work I've seen here so I tried to make as little change as possible - especially since I wanted to retain the looks of the original case front and back.

Some of you might have noticed the case was completely empty, so there was no top shelf to mount anything to, no power supply to reuse, no cable for the front panel... Well, that didn't go so well. So I bought another case, this time not caring too much about the wear level.

05.jpg


With a lot of enthusiasm I started to dismantle the whole thing in the hallway of our flat. The wife is not happy.

At least now I should have all the parts I need, don't I? Well... Wait, there were some changes with the Late 2005 models? Other power plug? Directly connected front panel? *!?"*§"! I ended up using only the top shelf and the hard drive bay, although even the bay had to be modified because they changed some standoffs with the 2005 model. :(

Now to the fun part: JB welding the standoffs to the right place.

06.jpg


One first test fit - it's a tight fit, but it's a fit!

07.jpg

08.jpg


I wasn't going to change the rear panel because of the asthetics and my poor skills with metal - I've seen that on the G4 already, no need to repeat that again.
Because I really don't need a graphics card for my usage I decided to only cut a little piece out to be able to use the DisplayPort connector of the mainboard.

11.jpg


I don't need the other ports - there are plenty USB headers on board and I wouldn't have used onboard audio anyhow because of it's inferior quality.

12.jpg


The back fans were mounted into the original place, for the front fan I had to drill holes to mount it to the top shelf. I was thinking of adding another fan right underneath this one, but I've got enough airflow as it is now. The CPU is cooled passively, only using the airflow from the front fan and the two rear fans and it is idleing at around 30° celsius, with Prime95 heat of about 65° celsius - that's really nice considering the low noise emission of my setup.

In the meantime I bought another G5, this time looking for the right model. I only needed the power supply (for the power connector) and the original power cord, but I got this one so cheap I even made some money out of it. But still: driving several G5 cases around, dismantling another one, like the others filled with a lot of dust... doesn't make the wife happy.

For the hard disk I built a case out of the old PowerMac DVD drive where I put several layers of bitumen to cool the drive while damping the noise (I wasn't happy with the WD Green's noise level even though it should be one of the quieter drives with two platters).

13.jpg

14.jpg


With some twisting I was able to fit this box into the old power supply housing next to the new power supply.

About two and a half months after starting this project it's finally finished. I'm impressed by the noise level as I hardly can hear the fans (all using the ultra low noise adapters to 7 volts, resulting in very little rpms). The hard disk is pretty quiet now, though with a SSD only it would be even better - if only 1-2 TB SDDs would be affordable some time soon.

15.jpg

16.jpg

17.jpg

18.jpg

19.jpg

20.jpg

21.jpg


The wife will be happy again, sometime.
 
Thank you!
The rear fans are PWM and the board will only power one of them if the temps are low (idle), but the front fan is non-PWM and has to run at a fixed speed. However I think that with the BIOS settings I may have a chance to do something similar as now I have the from fan set at "full speed" (it won't turn on otherwise, you can see it try to turn the fan once on "normal" setting), but with a high enough PWM to celsius ratio in BIOS I may be able to get it running under heavy load - I'll have a look at it!

EDIT: The case fan headers on the board are actually 3 pin voltage regulation headers that do support 4 pin fans too - however they don't regulate via PWM but via voltage, so it is ideal for me. I entered the highest ratio for the front fan (it needs some voltage to run, especially with the low noise adapter I'm using (droping the voltage already to 9v). I did a quick test with Geekbench, but it won't heat my i5 over 45° celsius so the system temperature isn't rising - no chance to see the front fan running anytime soon. :D Maybe it will turn on in high summer, but for now it is one fan less which lowers the noise even more (though the fan was hardly audible before). If there was no HDD you couldn't tell if the system is running or not. ;)
 
How is the HDD temp being sealed in an insulated box the way it is?
 
It actually went down from 32 degrees celsius to 28 degrees because of the added surface to spread the heat.
 
Update: After the Fusion Drive failing I decided to swap both SSD & HDD out of the system for a nice 750 GB Samsung 840 Evo - the prices have dropped a bit since the end of last year so it wasn't as big a decision as back then. Now I really can speak of a inaudible setup as the only sound you hear when waking the system from sleep is the DVD drive doing its short check, afterwards there's simply nothing to hear even at close distance. And of course the system gained some speed, which is a nice bonus.
 
Thanks for the great pictures, learned a lot for my project.

Thanks again, and nice build! :)
 
I love your build!
Very clean and simple.
I love my SSD's as you said they need to lower $ and be more reliable but I guess that will come in time.
Very nice build:clap:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top