Contribute
Register

best motherboard for USB2/3.0 compatibility and Thunderbolt support?

Status
Not open for further replies.
While I have the the GA-Z77X-UP5 TH, and am very satisfied with it, I agree with Einsteiniac that your requirements describe an actual Mac or a quality Windows machine.

I see you got the UP5 TH. in terms of thunderbolt (if you use them) are you satisfied with the purchase of the motherboard.
im debating on which to get GA-Z77X-UD5H or UP5 TH. I've read many threads on Thunderbolt working but they are not hot swappable. Thats not a big deal as long as they work on Apple Thunderbolt display on a minimum level. thanks in advance.
 
While I waited for release info from Apple though, I read the threads here and eventually learned enough about the process and available hardware to make it work. It was a real toss-up for a long time though.
Agreed (with the rest of the post too btw). Having had some experience from the Tiger days, mostly quite bad-but-usable, I spent about two months reading up on things here before I decided to go for a Hack instead of a new Mac. I then waited another month or two before I could get the right parts that I wanted. Patience is key. If you don't have the patience, the will to read and learn, and the will to accept that there will be problems, in some shape or form, don't get a Hack. Spend the dough and buy a real Mac. It's all good, but you need to accept that they are two different beasts.
 
While I have the the GA-Z77X-UP5 TH, and am very satisfied with it, I agree with Einsteiniac that your requirements describe an actual Mac or a quality Windows machine.

Setting up my machine was really easy thanks to the threads you called unhelpful. I spent weeks reading the threads and crafting my hardware list. Because of the threads, I knew which problems I was likely to encounter and how to fix almost all of them. I had also decided which problems with my setup I could live with -like no wake from Bluetooth.

The fact of the matter is, a Hackintosh is gonna have problems from time-to-time, but the members of those unhelpful threads pool their knowledge and generally come up with solutions quickly. That's not always the case though, you might encounter a problem that takes a long time to solve or doesn't have a solution at all, and you have to be willing to live with the problem.

If that process is unappealing and you find this community unhelpful, a Hack probably isn't a good fit for your needs. Believe me, I understand. I spent months reading the threads before I decided a Hack wasn't too risky to try. Along the way, I decided on several occasions that it sounded like too much bother. In fact if Apple had released a serious update to the Mac Pros this summer or fall, I would have bought one of those instead. While I waited for release info from Apple though, I read the threads here and eventually learned enough about the process and available hardware to make it work. It was a real toss-up for a long time though.

Hi Felix, thanks for your contribute. I guess you miserunderstand what I wrote before (due to my poor english surely, I'm sorry for that). I've never thought and/or told that here there are "unhelpful threads by which everyone pools his knowledge" . Or at least it's never been my intention. Infact the sharing of this knowledge is very valuable.

The point is that every bit and piece of this whole knowledge leads ultimately to an uncomplete puzzle in which every single build - including the golden ones - has its quircks, its pros and cons and there is no clear vision of what you can surely get from a build and what you cannot. Many of them, with the exact same pieces of hardware, lead to completely different results, provided with different version of MultiBeast, kexts, bios versions and so forth. For a complete noob, such as I am, this can be a bit erratic and chaotic.

[OT] Infact even if what I'm about to say is OT in this thread, the only one thing that I feel like to suggest to moderators of this website, is to not only give advices about the right pieces of hardware to buy, but to develop and maintain some preferred builds during the time and along the MB, bios, updates, and drivers are improved or simply changed. Maybe with a coordinator that collect all the experiences made by users on that choosen build. [end of OT]


That said, what I'm looking for is not a shortcut to have my build up and running perfectly. My aim is less ambitious and much less spoilt (as some in this 3d have thought!): I often exchange great amount of data with external hard drives connected via USB2 and recently (a bless!) USB3 ports. Thunderbolt is just an option for the future at the moment. So I need to be sure that I'll be able to transfer file like before. That's it.

This does not mean that I don't want to deal with the difficulties to build an osx86 machine... it's only that I'd like - after a learning curve - to count on a reliable result! ;)
 
Yo, I will add that the Asus Z77 Thunderbolt board worked great when we had it. Sleep, Wake from Sleep, USB2/3, Thunderbolt, etc..... Got rid of it since I couldn't get Lion to be stable. Found out later it may not have been stable without Mountain Lion.

Anyway, good luck with your search for the best machine for your needs.
 
Agreed (with the rest of the post too btw). Having had some experience from the Tiger days, mostly quite bad-but-usable, I spent about two months reading up on things here before I decided to go for a Hack instead of a new Mac. I then waited another month or two before I could get the right parts that I wanted. Patience is key. If you don't have the patience, the will to read and learn, and the will to accept that there will be problems, in some shape or form, don't get a Hack. Spend the dough and buy a real Mac. It's all good, but you need to accept that they are two different beasts.

Hi BitterMelon and thanks for your contribute. Patience and knowledge is the key. Indeed.

And for a while I really entertained myself with the idea to go for a new iMac 27" but, at the end, I thought that investing 1700€ for a machine that can have a maximum of 2 HDDs (Fusioned together) and no other chance to expand (apart from RAM)is not suitable for my needs. I've always been using quality Windows machines and quite happy with them after all. But I have at least 4 big and internal HDDs right now and I want to keep them and I want a reasonable ability to expand my rig if needed. Normally a desktop pc has an average lifetime of 3 or 4 years in my home/office so I don't want to give up with that expandability.

And sure I know that Hack and Mac are two different beasts but I really would like to give a serious try to OSX which I'm liking more and more as I discover it. But here serious means a build that I can reliably work with.
 
Yo, I will add that the Asus Z77 Thunderbolt board worked great when we had it. Sleep, Wake from Sleep, USB2/3, Thunderbolt, etc..... Got rid of it since I couldn't get Lion to be stable. Found out later it may not have been stable without Mountain Lion.

Anyway, good luck with your search for the best machine for your needs.

thanks you! which model exactly? the P8Z77-V Premium or P8Z77-V Pro/Thunderbolt?
 
And that is what the advanced search engine is for. Please read the FAQ - http://www.tonymacx86.com/faq.php
Please use the search function before creating a topic. The question that you ask may have already been answered.

Hi Going Bald and thank for your contribute.

Even if the question that I ask may have already been answered - and I'm pretty sure it's been and it still will ;) - as I's already pointed out in this thread past answers could be or could be not right or still valid for everyone's specific need. Even if all of them are very valuably as are an importantpart of the whole knowledge in OSX86 experience.

In other words it seems to me that if the whole hack process is intrinsecly a continuos working in progress, then all the answers are partial by definition, and it's always necessary to tightly tailor the questions and the related answers not only on our own needs but also to the state of art (if any!) of the hack experience at present time.

That said, I'm doing many research on this site and elsewhere to try to collect as more infos as I can. ;)
 
[OT] Infact even if what I'm about to say is OT in this thread, the only one thing that I feel like to suggest to moderators of this website, is to not only give advices about the right pieces of hardware to buy, but to develop and maintain some preferred builds during the time and along the MB, bios, updates, and drivers are improved or simply changed. Maybe with a coordinator that collect all the experiences made by users on that choosen build. [end of OT]

This is what the WiKi is for and everyone is encouraged to add their hardware and what they did to make it work. See
http://legacy.tonymacx86.com/wiki/index.php/Main_Page and http://legacy.tonymacx86.com/wiki/index.php/Wiki_Guidelines#Intro_to_Wiki_Formatting and http://legacy.tonymacx86.com/wiki/index.php/Wiki_Guidelines
 
I see you got the UP5 TH. in terms of thunderbolt (if you use them) are you satisfied with the purchase of the motherboard.
im debating on which to get GA-Z77X-UD5H or UP5 TH. I've read many threads on Thunderbolt working but they are not hot swappable. Thats not a big deal as long as they work on Apple Thunderbolt display on a minimum level. thanks in advance.

I bought the UP5 TH to future-proof the system a little, so I'm only using one Thunderbolt port to connect a DVI monitor via an adapter. I've also extensively read that hot swap doesn't work. Thunderbolt devices need to come way down in price before I'll spring for one.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top