- Joined
- Jan 5, 2020
- Messages
- 478
- Motherboard
- MSI Z690 Force
- CPU
- i9-13900K
- Graphics
- RX 590
- Mac
Unfortunately that exhausts the various options I can think of. Thunderbolt monitors are very finicky on Hackintosh and should ideally be avoided.
I'll post a warning at the top of Post 1 to avoid Thunderbolt monitors and some Corsair "smart" devices (including Corsair Commander Pro).
It was worth a try. Thanks again for trying! I did solve the problem of the computer turning back on at shutdown by turning OFF wake from thunderbolt device in the bios.
I went back to Alex's SSDT that you modified and posted yesterday. I still have the issue with the sounds, camera, etc disabling after sleep, but all is good before sleep.
Here is a quick comparison of my experiences with flashed Titan Ridge(with GC-TITAN-RIDGE-NVM23-Elias64Fr.bin) and unflashed Alpine Ridge AIC with the Apple TBD:
Flashed Titan Ridge 1.0 AIC:
Pros:
- Apple USB bus within the monitor stays on after sleep, maintaining speakers, camera, USB ports on back of display
- Active TB bus that supports hot swapping
- Sleep works normally
Cons:
- Display doesn't turn on till part way through the boot up cycle. Requires a second monitor or ghost plug to boot into Mac OS.
- Monitor does not always turn on after sleep. Requires unplugging the TB cable and plugging back in to wake display up. Speakers and USB 2.0 devices in display still work after doing the hot plug.
- More cable management required and larger footprint. Needs power supply cable and USB 2.0 header cable.
Unflashed Apple Ridge Card 2.0 AIC:
Pros:
- Apple TBD turns on at post. Allowing for bios modifications or choosing a different operating system.
- Fewer cables to connect(no USB 2.0 header cable and no requirement for an additional power supply cable).
- No flashing required to use an apple TBD.
- Sleep works normally
Cons:
- USB 2.0 bus disappears after sleep along with other thunderbolt devices in the display. Speakers, Ethernet, USB hub on display, FaceTime camera stop working after sleep. Needs a restart to reeenable.
TBD:
- Does monitor turn on reliably after sleep?
Compared to my flashed Titan Ridge AIC, having the monitor turn on at post is definitely a huge plus. If the monitor turns on consistently after sleep, I'll probably stay with AR and hope I can eventually solve the issue with the USB 2.0 devices disappearing after sleep. I can always plug in an external speaker, and just do a restart to reactivate the camera(which I rarely use). In either case, it's definitely usable. I think the behavior with Titan Ridge is acceptable for those that have a second monitor always plugged in all the time. AR is better for a single monitor setup. I got around then need for a second monitor by using the HDMI ghost plug(your suggestion a few months ago!). I do plug in a second monitor if I need to get into the bios with TR. The alternative with TR is to boot into macOS, and then sometimes at restart the monitor stays active so you can go into the bios or select a different OS in the picker.
One more observation using the SSDT from Alex, before sleep I see devices under PCI with Thunderbolt@.
After sleep, only the Alpine Ridge entry remains which I guess is the crux of the problem. How to get the Thunderbolt@ devices to reconnect after sleep. I see a couple other message threads in the SSDT section. I'll hunt around for potential solutions and report back if I find one. I am running Mojave, so small chance something may be fixed with an update.
Last edited: